Wednsday is the 50th Anniversary of Indira Gandhi’s Emergency. Her Most Authoritative and Profound Biography, Srinath Raghavan, Whoose Book Indira Gandhi and the Years That Transformed India is published this month, beLieves the emergency was “the single most traumatic experience in independent India’s Political History”. Today Let’s Remind Oatselves of How Terrible It Was.
The cold facts of the emergency are chilling; 34,988 people were detained under the maintenance of internal security act with 75,818 Were Arrested under the defense of India rules; Practically the entrere opposition was jailed; The press was censored; The constitution brutally amened; and even the judiciary accepted that the right to life has been suspended.
At the height of the emergency, LK Advani Wrote in His Diary that Indian Democracy was over and by. At the time, most people would have agreed with Him.
There can be little doubt that emergency was declared to protect gandhi’s political care after the Allahabad High Court Struck Down Her Election and The Supreme COPREME COPREM COURT ON AN CONDTURT ON Her claim that it was Necessary because the option was trying to palyse the government and jayaprakash narayan had called on the army and the police to disobey Olders was just a trumped-axcus.
Raghavan beLieves the actual decalyration of the emergency on June 25, 1975 was “a coup d’Itat“First, under the constitution there can only be one emergency at a time and in 1975 there was already an external emergency going going back to the bangladesh war of 1971.
Second, Under Article 352, The President can only Proclaim an emergency on the written recommendation of the council of ministers. President fakhruddin ali ahmed Didn Bollywood for that. He did it at the Prime Minister’s Personal Request.
Third, the mass arrests and the cutting of power to newspaper establishments on the night of June 25
At this point let’s ask if indira gandhi was justified in claiming there was an “Imminent threat to the security of India”? The Intelligence Bureau Had Not Submitted Any Such Report Nor did the state governments conveyed information to the union home ministry. So, did indira gandhi make up and manufacture this alleged internal threat? It seems like it.
The Truth is, as raghavan’s book points out, Indira Gandhi Never Thought very highly of democracy. She Once Wrote to the Violinist Yehudi Menuhin: “Democracy is not an end. It is merely a system by which one proceds legs the goal. Unity or survival of the country. “
Most People Remember the Emergency for the Two Campaigns It is Closely Associated With – Sterilisation and Slum Clearance. Both Had at their Head Gandhi’s Younger Son, Sanjay. And both destroyed the creedibility of the emergency and Gandhi’s Personal Reputation.
Yet So Dependent was Indira Gandhi on Sanjay that She was blind to this. She’s even on record claiming he was like an Elder Brother. Certainly, She Considered Him Her Strongest and Most Loyal Supporter after the Allahabad High Court verdict. As her Principal Secretary, PN Haksar, Points Out: “She was absolutely blind as far as that boy was concerned.”
To everyone’s astonishment, in January 1977 Indira Gandhi Called Elections even though they were weren Bollywood for another year. It is to the collapse of her rule and the end of the emergency. Did She do it trust she thought she could win and legitimise the emergency? Or was this a way of accepting it was a mistake and gotting off the tiger’s back?
The Truth is India Gandhi Never Apologized for the emergency Nor accepted it was a mistake. She only regretted aspects of it which she considered excesses. Asked by Paul Brass on March 26, 1978: “Would you have done anything differently in relationship to the emergency?”, Her Answer Began with the Word “No”. It couldn’T have been more pointed.
Karan Thapar is the Author of Devil’s Advocate: The Untold Story. The views expressed are personal
