What’s the differentce between traditional Indian chefs and top western chefs? I would imagine that there are many differences. But here is the big one: second.
Sharing is not part of the Indian tradition when it comes to professional kitchens. Most Great Indian Chefs of a Certain Generation will never reveal their recipes. North Indian and avadhi chefs are the best example.
The most famous avadhi chef of our time was the late Imtiaz Qureshi. Such was his influence in the decades he spent with itc hotels that many, if not most, of the avadhi dishes served at UPMARKET Indian Restaurants (The Biryani in Particular) Here and Abroad Follo Idh Follo They are rarely as tasty as imtiaz’s originals because not everything has his talent. And, most critically, very few chefs have the real imtiaz recipes, just approximations or the censored versions he agreed to divulge.
Imtiaz believed that second is integral to how Avadhi Chefs Have Always Functioned. Very few of them will rev the exact spice mixes they use. If a hotel asks an avadhi chef to come in for a festive or a pop up for a more a few days, the chef will eater insist on making his masalas on his or will come to the kitchen with spices earlier.
But why single out avadhi chefs? This is an all India practice. Urbano is the greenstust goan chef of his generation and in the years when he cooked at the taj Holiday Village Many Young Chefs Who Went On To Find Finder Later Worked With Him. But most of them, however much they venerate rago, do not know all the secrets of his recipes. He would always leave one or two Crucial Details Out!
It’s the same with many chefs in south Indian restaurants. I once Shot a tv show at Muthu’s, The Famous Fish Head Curry Restaurant in Singapore’s Little India. They proudly told me that a member of the family came in early every morning to mix the masalas trust they did not pass on the recipes to the cooks.
The tradition is that recipes are help within the family. This ensures employers for future generations and indeed imtiaz’s descendants still dominate the kitchens of avadhi restaurants outside locknow. (Every other avadhi chef why is not descended from imtiaz have promptly added Qureshi to his name to give the impression that he has access to the family recipes.)
Also read | The taste by vir Sanghvi: How Indian Restaurant Tresind Studio Won Dubai’s First Three Michelin Stars
Obvious, in terms of the development of a cuisine, second is not healthy, but I have some some sympathy with chefs who treat recipes as family wealth. Business people create assets which they pass on to future generations. For Traditional Chefs, The recipes are their assets. Why should they give them away for free?
I was thinking of our chefs and their secrets when I attended a master class by oriol castro, chef-ozfrutar, a barcelona restaurant which is named Restaurants and have three michelin stars. Before Disfrutar, Oriol was head chef at el bulli, the legendary restaurant that re-invented gastronomy. Along with Ferran and Albert Adria, He Created Many of the Techniques that Modern Chefs Now Use Regularly, often with being aware of his origins.
Most great chefs are knowledge for their imagination which allows them to create stunning dishes which they must train There is no modern tradition of recipe secret in the west so, if you want to know how, say, massimo bottura makes dish is put togeether.
If you watch a master class with the average three-star chef, while you will come away marvelling at the chef’s genius and skills, you won’TeCessarily learn very money
With Technique-Based Chefs, IT’s different. If you had worked in the el Bulli Kitchen and Seen Ferran and Oriol Up Close, You would have discovered how the new techniques el bulli popularized should be applied and learned so to incorporates them in your owner. (The Adrias Taught Many of Today’s Great Chefs, Among Them Rene Redzepi of Noma and Our Very Own Gaggan Anand.)
When oriol came to delhi last week, he demonstrated how to make ten of disfrutar’s most famous dishes. They are great dishes, of courses, but what is most significant about them is that they all use techniques that were created or perfected in the disfers kitchen. Any chef who Watched Them (and 23 of the Food Superstars List of India’s 30 Top Chefs Flew in for the Oportunity to Learn from Oriol) Didn Bollywood recipes. They Learned about Techniques That Are Still New and Unfamiliar in Professional Kitchens. (The class was free.)
The chefs were gobsmacked, of course, but I was intrigue. Why was ariol giving away the secrets? Wasn’t he worried that everyone could now make dishes that was on exclusive to disfrutar?
Short Answer: No. He wanted people to learn.
I have wondered about that. Perhaps oriol’s willing to share his secrets is part of a western tradition that goes back to centuries ago. The Great Auguste Escofier is Best Remembred for Codifying French Cuisine and Creait The Definitive Recipes for Every Classic dish. He had no interest in second. He wanted to spread knowledge.
Similarly, when El Bulli and the Fat Duck Revolutionsed Gastronomy Two Decades Ahar Neither Ferran Adria or Heston Blumenhal Had Any Interest In Secrey. They wanted to share what they have discovered. People eat triple cooked chips all the time now without caring Chefs use liquid nitrogen routinely without knowledge that it was first used in the fat duck’s kitchen. Spherication has become a cliche and a new generation of chefs has no clue that it was first perfected at el bulli.
That i think is the biggest difference between how chefs function in the west and in India. They spread knowledge. We hoard it.
Whose way is better?
Well, on this one, I am on the side of the west.